System for measuring radioactivity



June 22, 1954 J. F. CLAYTON ET AL 0. SYSTEM FOR MEASURING RADIOACTIVITY Filed May 31, 1951 6 POWER SUPPLY IlO m w i q- N ro x (:5 n e n:

w w L C) no 0 Q l .LNBHHHO HlV'ld a: E 0. '2 O 8 o 3 9 0 8 to w 22 2 'g m v 81 (9% EH N l w z a) 5 5 5 g 5%?!" a; o N E20) W (9 o afi M s; f

1 w :0 8 co JNVENTOR. JOSEPH F. CLAYTON ALEXANDER GREENFIELD m gm.

ATTORNEY powen SUPPLY FIG.I

Patented June 22, 1954 2,682,000 SYSTEM FOR MEASURING RADIOAGTIVITY Joseph F. Clayton and Alexander Greenfield, Detroit, Mich., assignors to Bendix Aviation Corporation, Detroit, Mich, a corporation of Delaware Application May 31, 1951, Serial No. 229,227

8 Claims.

This invention relates to a system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity and more particularly to a system for accurately measuring the intensity of radioactivity over a wide range of values.

In recent years, the development of uses for atomic energy, both for peace and war, has proceeded at a rapid pace. Because of the potentially widespread applications for atomic energy resulting from these developments, it has become extremely urgent to make available for general use apparatus for measuring the intensity of radioactivity in a particular locality and for providing an instantaneous indication of the measurement. The apparatus should be capable of measuring the radioactivity over a wide range of values and should provide distinct warnings, either visual or audible or both, when the radioactivity approaches a danger level. The apparatus should also be portable and relatively inexpensive in order to have widespread use in such civilian places as the home, omce and factory as well as in ships, airplanes and other equipment having possible military application.

Until now, satisfactory apparatus has not been developed in spite of considerable efiorts by many people. Some of the apparatus has been unsatisfactory because it has not provided an accurate measurement of the radioactivity under ordinary conditions. Other apparatus has not measured the radioactivity over a sufficiently wire range or has been too complex, bulky or expensive.

This invention provides apparatus for acourately measuring the intensity of radioactivity The apparatus over a wide range of values. minimizes any errors in measurement by producing two voltages, one unaffected by the radioactivity to serve as a reference level and the other varied from the reference level in accordance with the intensity of radioactivity. The apparatus operates to obtain an indication of the intensity of radioactivity by a comparison of the variable voltage and the reference voltage. An instantaneous reading of the intensity of radioactivity is provided by an indicator having a plurality of scales, each scale being adapted to cover a difierent range, and by a switching circuit operative to specifically point out the scale to be read.

An object of this invention is to provide apparatus for accurately measuring the intensity of radioactivity in a particularly locality.

Another object of the invention is to provide apparatus of the above character for providing an instantaneous and reliable indication of the intensity of radioactivity over a wide range of values. 4,

A further object is to provide apparatus of the above character having an indicator with a plurality of scales for showing dilferent ranges of radioactivity and a switching circuit operative on the indicator to point out instantaneously the scale that should be read.

Still another object is to provide a system of the above character for giving a definite warning when the radioactivity approaches a danger level.

A still further object is to provide a system of the above character which is relatively light, compact and inexpensive and which has a minimum number of parts connected in an electrical and mechanical arrangement to operate for long periods of time without any requirements for repair.

Other objects and advantages will be apparent from a detailed description of the invention and from the appended drawings and claims.

In the drawings:

Figure 1 is a circuit diagram of one embodiment of the invention; and

Figure 2 is a curve illustrating the operational characteristics of an important tube in the circuit shown in Figure 1.

In one embodiment of the invention, an ionization chamber is provided. The chamber includes a sealed cylinder l2 made from brass or copper or any other material with a high electron density. A suitably pressurized gas such as argon is contained within the cylinder, and a rod (4 is axially disposed within the cylinder in insulated relationship to the cylinder. The cylinder I2 is grounded and a negative voltage such as volts, is applied on the rod from a series circuit including resistances l6, l8 and 22 and a power supply 24 adapted to supply a negative voltage. The resistances I6 and it have values of approximately 10,000 and 30,000 megohms, respectively, and the resistance 22 has a value of approximately one megohm or less.

The rod 54 is connected to the grid of a pentode 25 having its cathode and suppressor grid con nected to the power supply 24 through a resistance 28 and the resistance 22 in series. The cathode and suppressor grid of a pentode 30 are connected to the cathode of the tube 26 and to a resistance 32, which is in series with a grounded resistance 30. The control grid of the pentode 30 is connected to the common terminal between the resistances 22 and 28. The plates and screen grids of the pentodes 25 and 30 are connected through equal resistances 36 and 38, respectively, to the common terminal between the resistances 32 and 34.

Connections are also made from the plate of the tube 2.6 to the grids of triodes 40, 42 and 44 and from the plate of the tube 30 to the grid of tubes 45, 48 and 50. The plates of the tubes 46 and it are connected through equal resistances i2 and 54, respectively, to a positive power supply 55; to a stationary contact and the movable contact, respectively, of a potentiometer 58; and

to the terminals of an indicator 6D. The cathodes oi the tubes 56 and 4B are connected to the stationary contacts of a potentiometer I52, the movable contact of which is connected to a resistance 64. The resistance 64 is in turn connected to the power supply 24.

The cathodes of the tubes 42 and 4B are connected through a commonresistance 68 to the power supply 24, and the plates of the tubes are respectively connected to the movable contact of a potentiometer 68 and to one side of a resistance I0. Connections are made from a stationary contact of the potentiometer 68 and the other side of the resistance In to the power supply 58. A connection is also made from the plate to the tube 42 to the grid of a tube '34.

Negative voltage from the power supply 24 is applied through a resistance it to the cathodes of the tubes 44 and 50. The plate of the tube 44 is connected to the grid of a tube 18 and to the movable contact of a potentiometer 5i which is in series with a resistance 82 and the power supply 56. Positive voltage from the power supply 56 is applied to the plate of the tube 50 through a resistance 86.

The cathodes of the tubes I4 and I8 are grounded and the plates are connected to one side of solenoids 88 and 90, respectively, having their other side connected to the power supply 56. Ganged switches 92, 94, 96 and 98 are associated with the solenoid 88, the switch 92 being nor-- mally closed and the other switches being nor mally open, and ganged switches let, I02, Ill-4, Hit, 108 and H8 are associated with the solenoid 90. The switch I02 is normally closed and the other switches are normally open.

The movable contact of the switch 92 is connected to the left terminal of a light bulb IE2 having its right terminal connected to ccrresponding terminals of bulbs IM and lit. As disclosed in co-pending application Serial No. 159,105, filed April 29, 1956, by Fred N. .Blackmore and Donald Clinton, the light bulbs II2, I I4 and IIS are suitably positioned within the indicator 59 to cast distinctively colored lights on the face of the indicator when they are energized. For example, the light bulb IIZ may cast a white light, the bulb ill! a green light and the bulb H6 a red light. Power for the bulbs I I2, H4 and I It is supplied by a filament power supply I H.

A plurality of scales M3, E28 and I22 are provided on the face of the indicator Gil and are distinctively colored in accordance with the colored illumination cast by the light bulbs. Each scale has a progressively increasing range. For example, the white scale IIS may provide indications between and milliroentgens per hour, the green scale I indications between 0 and 50 milliroentgens per hour, and the red scale I22 indications between 0 and 2000 milliroentgens per hour.

The stationary contact of'the switch 92 is con nected to the stationary contact of the switch 94, the movable contact or" which is connected to the left terminal of the bulb I I5, and is also connected to the movable contact of'the switch I02, which has its stationary contact grounded. Connec tions are made from the stationary contact of the switch 96 to the left terminal of the indicator 8G and from the movable contact of the switch to the movable contact of a potentiometer I24 ,having one of its stationary contacts connected to the right terminal of the indicator 60. The mov able contact of the switch 98 is grounded and. the stationary contact is connected to one side of a warning indicator 2B, the other side of which is connected through a resistance l28 to the power supply 56. The indicator 126 may be located at a position removed from the ionization chamber ill to provide a suitable warning when the radioactivity approaches an. intensity providing a moderate danger. For example, the indicator I26 may be located in the cockpit of an airplane to provide a distinctive sound or to provide a green light corresponding to the color of the bulb IM and the scale I20 when the intensity of radioactivity becomes dangerous in the body of the plane.

The movable contact of the switch I09 has voltage from the power supply 56 applied to it through a resistance I30 and the stationary contact is connected to a grounded solenoid I32. A normally open switch i34 is actuated by the solenoid I32 and is connected across the resistance I8. The stationary contact of the switch I94 is grounded and the movable contact is connected to the left terminal of the light bulb I6. The stationary contact of the switch I06 is connected to the left terminal of the indicator Be and the movable contact is connected to the movable contact of a potentiometer I36, a stationary contact of which is connected to the right terminal of the indicator 60.

Connections are made from the stationary .contact of the switch I08 to the common terminal between the resistance 80 and the potentiometer 82 and from the movable contact of the switch to the power supply 56. The movable contact of the switch Ilfiis grounded and the stationary contact is connected to one side of a warning indicator I38. The other side of the indicator 138 is connected through a resistance I40 to the power supply'56. The indicator I33 provides a warning, either visual or audible, to indicate that the radioactivity is approaching a level of severe danger. This warning is different from the warning provided by the indicator I26.

Each radioactive pulse, such as a gamma radiation, which penetrates the ionization chamber ID from the space surrounding the chamber imparts suflicient energy to the walls of the chamber to cause some of the electrons to break away from the inner wall. cylindrical wall I2 travel into the chamber before being attracted back to the cylindrical wall by the positive voltage on the wall relative to the negative potential on the rod it. Some of the electrons strike molecules of argon during their cycle of travel and produce an ionization of the 53 argon molecules into electrons and positive ions.

The electrons produced from the argon are attracted towards the cylindrical wall I2 and the positive ions are attracted towards the rod I4. As a result, an electric current is produced which flows through the resistances IE, IS, 28, 32 and 34. Practically all of the voltage produced by the ionization current occurs across the resistances I6 and IB, since the resistances I6 and I8 are considerably greater than the resistances 2B, 32 and 34. This voltage diiference, which is in the order of a millivolt, produces an increase in the voltage on the grid of the tube 26 and causes the current through the tube to increase.

Before the apparatus shown in Figure 1 is placed in operation, the tubes 26 and .30 are matched to have substantially identical operational characteristics. Therefore, for a condition of no radioactivity, substantially equal currents flow through the tubes and produce equal voltages 5; on the tube plates, since the voltages applied on The electrons leaving the corresponding elements of each tube are substantially equal. However, when a voltage drop is produced across the resistances l6 and I8 by the ionization current, the current through the tube 26 increases and causes the voltage on the plate of the tube 26 to drop below the voltage on the plate of the tube 30. The difference in the voltages on the plates of the tubes 26 and 30 is substantially proportional to the intensity of radioactivity over a Wide range of values. The substantially linear characteristic of the tube 26 is illustrated in Figure 2, which shows how the voltage on the plate of the tube varies from a normal value, indicated at I 42, when changes appear in the voltage on the grid.

The voltage on the plate of the tube 30 controls the current through the tube 46. This current flows through a portion of the potentiometer 62 and through the resistance 64 and produces a predetermined voltage on the oathode of the tube. The voltage which appears on the cathode of the tube 49 is dependent upon the voltage on the cathode of the tube 46 since the resistance 64 is common to both tubes. The current which flows through the tube is is in turn dependent upon the difference in the vo1tages on the cathode and grid of the tube, the grid voltage being introduced from the plate of the tube 26. Since the resistance 64 is common to the tubes 46 and 40, the tube 46 provides a stabilizing action on the operation of the tube 40. This stabilizing action is instrumental in minimizing any errors which result from changes in the reference voltage applied from the plate of the tube 30 to the grid of the tube 48.

Since the difference in the Voltages on the plates of the tubes 48 and 40 is controlled by the difference in the voltages on the plates 26 and 30, it is also proportional to the intensity of radioactivity. This difference in voltages is produced by a gradual cutting-oil? of the tube 4!! as the intensity of radioactivity increases, causing the voltages on the plate of the'tube 40 to increase gradually above the voltage on the plate of the tube 46. The voltage difference appears across the indicator B0 and produces a proportionate deflection of the pointer positioned in the face of the indicator. The sensitivity of movement of the pointer for different intensities of radioactivity is dependent upon the shunting action provided by the potentiometer 58, which is connected directly across the indicator. The sensitivity of the indicator is generally adjusted before the initial operation of the apparatus disclosed above and is only occasionally adjusted thereafter.

The reference voltage on the plate of the tube 30 is also introduced to the grid of the tube 453 so that the tube 48 will provide a reference voltage for the tube 42. The voltage on the grid of the tube 48 causes current to flow through the tube and the resistance 6E5 of such value that a slightly positive voltage is produced on the cathodes of the tubes 48 and 42 relative to the voltage on the grid'of the tube 42 even when no radioactivity is present in the locality. This causes a moderate current to flow through the tube 42 when no radioactivity is present and the voltage'on the plate of the tube to be depressed somewhat below the voltage from the power supply 56 because of the voltage drops produced across the potentiometer (58. As the intensity of radioactivity increases, however, the voltage on the grid of the tube 42 decreases and pro- .duces a gradual cutting-01f of the tube. This causes the voltage on the gradually rise.

plate of the tube to The initial voltage on the plate of the tube for a condition of no radioactivity and the change in voltage with variations in radioactivity can be adjusted by varying the position of the movable contact on the potentiometer 68.

The voltage on the grid of the tube N, which is normally cut ofi, increases with rises in the voltage on the plate of the tube 4.2. At a voltage corresponding to a predetermined intensity of radioactivity, such as 5 milliroentgens per hour, current starts to flow through the tube M from the power supply 56. The current through the tube l4 also flows through the solenoid 853 and energizes the solenoid, causing the switch 32 to open and the switches 84, and 98 to close. When the switch 92 opens, the continuous circuit through the bulb H2 is interrupted to indicate that the scale H8 should no longer be read because the intensity of radioactivity has brought the pointer to the end of the scale.

At the same time that the circuit to the bulb l l S is interrupted, the switch 96 closes and places the potentiometer l24 in parallel withthe potentiometer 58 and the indicator 80. Since the potentiometer 12 has a considerably'smaller value than the potentiometer 58, it reduces the sensitivity of the indicator ti! and causes the indicator to measure the medium range of radio activity covered by the scale I20 instead or the relatively narrow range covered by the scale H8. The bulb H4 is simultaneously illuminated by current flowing through a continuous circuit including the filament voltage supply I H, the light bulb M4, the switch 94 and the switch H32. Illuminating the light bulb I I4 causes a green light to be cast upon the face or" the indicator 59 to specifically point out that the scale l2!) should be read. The indicator I26 is also operated through a circuit including the power supply the resistance I28, the indicator 26 and the switch 98 to provide an external warning that the radioactivity has an intensity of moderate danger.

The tubes 44 and 5 operate in the same manher as the tubes 42 and 48 and cause the volt age on the plate of the tube 44 to increase gradually as the intensity of radioactivity increases. When the voltage on the plate of the tube 4 3 approaches a value corresponding to the maximum range of the scale I20, the normally cutoff tube 78 starts to conduct. The current through the tube 18 also flows through the sole-- noid 9!! and energizes the solenoid, causing the switch 502 to open and the switches ltd, 56 5, I65, Hi8 and lid to close. Upon the closure of the switch let, a continuous circuit is established which includes the power suppl 56, the resistance lBd, the switch it! and the solenoid I32. The resultant current through the solenoid i32 causes the switch I34 to close and the resistance [3 to be shorted.

The resistance I?! is shorted at an intensity of radioactivity corresponding to the beginning of a non-linear response by the tube 26, as illustrated at M4 in Figure 2. The non-linear response results when a large'ionization current flows through the resistances It and i8 and produces a voltage which makes the voltage on the grid of the tube 26 more positive than the voltage on the cathode. The positive voltage on the rid of the tube 26 causes the grid, rather than the plate, to receive any increase in electrons from the cathode. By shorting the resistance 58, the voltage on the grid of the tube decreases for a given ionization current and produces a reduction in the diiference between the voltage on the plate of the tube 26 and the reference voltage on the plate of the tube 30. This causes the response of the tube 26 to drop from the non-linear region M4 to a level M6 in the linear region below the level M2. In this way, the efiec tive range of linear response is considerably increased.

The switch I03 closes at the same time as the switch I34 and shorts the resistance 82 to ccmpensate for the shorting of the resistance With the resistance 82 shorted, the sensitivity of response of the tube 44 increases, and the voltage on the plate of the tube M remains at approximately the same value for a radioactivity corresponding to the'end of the scale as the value before the resistance 18 was shorted. l3ecause of the maintenance of the same voltage on the plate of the tube 44, the bias on the grid of the tube 18 continues to remain unchanged and current flows through the tube to maintain the solenoid 90 energized. However, current stops flowing through the solenoid 38 because of decrease in voltage on the plate of the tube 52. since the solenoid B8 is no longer energized, the switches 94 and 98 open to interrupt the circuits to the bulb I I4 and warning indicator i255, respectively.

Closure of the switch H36 when the solenoid 90 becomes energized places the potentiometer 13% in parallel with the potentiometer 58 and the indicator 6B. The potentiometer N36 has a low-- or value than either the potentiometer 58 or the potentiometer l, and increases the indi-- cator range to conform with the scale I22. The switch HM closes at the same time as the switch 506 and establishes a continuous circuit which includes the filament power supply H1, the bulb H6 and the switch. The resultant illumination of the bulb H5 causes a red light to be cast on the face ofthe indicator 60 to specifically point out that the scale I22 should be read. The warning indicator I38 is also simultaneously op-- erated by the closure of the switch H0.

The apparatus disclosed above has several irnportant advantages. It accurately measures the intensity of radioactivity over a wide range of values by providing a reference voltage and comparing a variable voltage with the reference voltage. The apparatus operates to vary the second voltage in accordance with the intensity of radioactivity in the vicinity of an ionization chamber and also in accordance with any slight changes in the reference voltage. By comparing the variable voltage with the reference voltage, a direct and accurate indication of the intensity of radioactivity over a relatively wide range of values is obtained. The range of accurate measurement is further widened by altering the sensitivity of the apparatus as it approaches the region of non-linearity, sothat the apparatus in effect operates through its linear range at least twice as it measures increasing intensities of ra-- di-oactivity. The accuracy of the measurements is not materially altered by any changes in tern perature orhumidity which may be encountered.

The apparatus disclosed above also provides an indicator having different scales, each scale being adapted to measure the intensity of radioactivity over progressively increasing values. A switching circuit is associated with the indicator to alter the sensitivity of the indicator in accordance with the scale to be read. The switching circuit is in turn operated by solenoids, each of which is prevented from having any current flow through it until an intensity of radioactivity is reached corresponding to the maximum range of a particular scale. By preventing any current from flowing-through each solenoid until its actuation is required, a positive operation of the switching circuit is insured.

In addition to the above advantages, the apparatus is relatively light and inexpensive. These features are especially important in making the apparatus available for many diiferent uses, civilian as Well as military. The relative simplicity of the apparatus also facilitates its widespread use, since the apparatus may be op erated for long periods of time with a minimum amount of repair and a maximum amount of reliability.

Although this invention has been disclosed and illustrated with reference to particular applications, the principles involved are susceptible of numerous other applications which will be apparent to persons skilledin the art. The invention is, therefore, to be limited only as indicated by the scope of the appended claims.

What is claimed is:

1. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, an ionization chamber for producing an electrical current proportion 21.]. to the intensity of radioactivity, a relatively high resistance connected to the ionization chamber to produce a voltage proportional to the current through the chamber, a pair of tubes each having a cathode, a grid and a plate, the grid and cathode of the first tube being connected across the resistance, means for biasing the girls of the tubes with equal voltages relative to the cathodes for a condition of no radioactivity, an indicator connected to the plate of each tube to measure the difference in voltages caused by the flow of current through the resistarms, a plurality of scales on the indicator, means for adjusting the sensitivity of the indicator to change from one scale to another scale having an increased range when the indication is at the end of the first scale and for instantaneously pointing out the scale to be read, means for partially shorting the resistance when the response of the first tube becomes non-linear and means for compensating for the reduction in voltage produced by the partial shorting of the resistance so as to provide a proper reading of the indicator.

2. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, an ionization chamber for converting radioactive emanations into an electrical current proportional to the intensity of the radioactivity, means for providing a ref crence voltage, variable means operative to pro-- duce a voltage different from the reference voltage by a value proportional to the electric current, means common to the reference means and the variable means to substantially eliminate the effects on the voltage difference of any variations in the reference voltage, an indicator connected to the variable means and to the reference means, a plurality of scales, each scale being adapted to indicate a different range of radio activity, and means operative in accordance with the difference voltage to adjust the sensitivity of the indicator for readings at the end of one scale and to instantaneously point out the next scale to be read.

3. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, .means for producing a current proportional to the intensity of radioactivity, means for converting the current into a proportionate voltage, means connected to the conversion means for indicating the voltage level, a plurality of scales on the indicating means for covering different ranges of radioactivity, a plurality of solenoids, means for normally preventing the new of current through each solenoid, means operative at a predetermined voltage level for each solenoid to produce a flow of current through the solenoid, and means operative by each solenoid upon the flow of current through the solenoid to reduce the sensitivity of the indicating means so as to increase its range.

4. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, an ionization chamber for producing an electrical current proportional to the intensity of radioactivity, means for converting the electrical current into a proportionate voltage, means for indicating the voltage, the indicating means having a plurality of scales, a plurality of solenoids, means for normally preventing an energizing current from flowing through each solenoid, means operative at predetermined voltages to energize the solenoids, means operative by each solenoid to provide a change from one scale to another scale having an increased range, and means operative by each solenoid to provide an instantaneous indication of the scale to be read.

5. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, an ionization chamber for producing an electrical current substantially proportionate to the intensity of radioactivity, a relatively high resistance connected to the ionization chamber to produce a voltage substantially proportionate to the current through the chamher, a first tube, a second tube, a power supply. the first tube being connected to the resistance and to the power supply to provide a relatively constant reference voltage, the second tube being connected to the resistance and to the ionization chamber to provide a variable voltage different from the reference voltage by a magnitude substantially proportionate to the voltage across the resistance, a third tube having a cathode, grid and plate, the grid of the third tube being connected to the first tube to receive the reference voltage from the first tube, a fourth tube having a cathode, grid and plate, the grid of the fourth tube being connected to the second tube toreceive the variable voltage from the tube, the third and fourth tubes having a common cathode resistance to minimize any effects on the fourth tube of variations in the reference voltage from the second tube, and an indicator connected between the plates of the third and fourth tubes to measure the difference in the output voltages from the tubes.

6. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, an ionization chamber for producing an electrical current substantially proportionate to the intensity of radioactivity, a relatively high resistance connected to the ionization chamber to produce a voltage substantially proportionate to the current through the chamber, reference means for providing a substantially constant reference voltage, variable means connected to the resistance for providing a voltage variable relative to the reference voltage in accordance with the value of the electrical current, first and second tubes connected respectively to the reference means and the variable means to produce a voltage indicative of any dif ference in the voltages provided by the reference 10 and variable means, impedance means common to the first and second tubes to substantially eliminate the effects on the voltage difference of any variations in the reference voltage applied to the first tube, and measuring means connected to the first and second tubes for indicating the difference in the voltages between them.

7. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, an ionization chamber for producing an electrical current proportional to the intensity of radioactivity, a relatively high resistance connected to the ionization chamber to produce a voltage proportional to the current through the chamber, a first tube for providing a substantially constant reference voltage, a second tube connected to the first tube for providing a voltage equal to the reference voltage for a condition of no radioactivity and connected to the resistance to provide a variation from the reference voltage by an amount dependent upon the voltage produced across the resistance, variable means connected to the first and second tubes to produce a voltage proportional to the difference in the voltages provided by the first and second tubes, an indicator connected to the variable means to measure the voltage produced by the variable means, means for reducing the value of the resistance upon a non-linear response of the second tube, and means for providing a corresponding adjustment in the sensitivity of the indicator upon the reduction in the value of the resistance.

8. A system for measuring the intensity of radioactivity, including, means for converting radioactive emanations into an electrical current proportional to the intensity of radioactivity, a relatively high impedance connected to the conversion means for producing a voltage proportional to the electrical current, a first tube for providing a reference voltage having a substantially constant amplitude, a second tube connected to the first tube and to the impedance for providing an output voltage variable relative to the reference voltage in accordance with the value of the voltage across the impedance, a third tube connected to the first tube to receive the output voltage from the first tube, a fourth tube connected to the second tube for providing between the third and fourth tubes a voltage substantially proportionate to the difference in the voltages between the first and second tubes, an impedance common to the third and fourth tubes for substantially eliminating the effects on the voltage difference of any variations in the reference voltage, and an indicator connected to the third and fourth tubes for measuring the difference voltage.

References Cited in the file of this patent UNITED STATES PATENTS Number Name Date 2,181,728 Greentree Nov. 28, 1939 2,469,460 Fearon May 10, 1949 2,491,904 Poole Dec. 20, 1949 2,541,039 Cole Feb. 13, 1951 2,609,512 Conviser Sept, 2, 1952 FOREIGN PATENTS Number Country Date 556,177 Great Britain Sept. 23, 1943 OTHER REFERENCES A Pulse Analyser for Nuclear Research, Freundlich et al., Rev. of Scientific Instr. February 1947, vol. 18, #2, pp. -100. 

